S&P Global downgraded Tether’s USDT stablecoin to a “weak” rating due to rising exposure to high-risk assets like Bitcoin and gold, coupled with limited disclosures. This could challenge USDT’s ability to maintain its dollar peg amid market volatility, though stronger transparency might improve future ratings.
-
S&P Global’s downgrade highlights USDT’s increased reserves in volatile assets such as BTC and gold, raising concerns over stability.
-
The rating shift from “constrained” to “weak” stems from insufficient transparency in Tether’s reserve composition.
-
USDT’s market cap exceeds $184 billion, with 77% backed by Treasury bills, but the rest includes riskier investments per S&P Global Ratings reports.
Discover why S&P Global downgraded USDT and Tether’s bold response. Explore risks, reserves, and implications for stablecoins in 2025. Stay informed on crypto stability—read now for expert insights.
What is the Reason Behind the USDT Downgrade by S&P Global?
The USDT downgrade by S&P Global Ratings reflects concerns over Tether’s growing allocation of reserves to high-risk assets, including Bitcoin and gold, alongside persistent transparency issues. The agency revised USDT’s rating from “constrained” to “weak,” noting that these exposures could jeopardize the stablecoin’s peg to the U.S. dollar during market turbulence. According to S&P Global Ratings, improved disclosures and reduced risk in reserves might lead to a rating upgrade in the future.
How Has Tether Responded to the Downgrade?
Tether’s CEO, Paolo Ardoino, strongly contested the downgrade, viewing it as an unfair critique of the company’s innovative reserve strategy. He argued that traditional financial systems rely on “toxic” assets, and Tether’s shift toward Bitcoin and gold exposes these flaws, prompting backlash from established rating agencies. S&P Global Ratings detailed that USDT’s reserves now encompass Bitcoin, gold, secured loans, corporate bonds, and other investments, all vulnerable to credit, market, interest-rate, and foreign-exchange risks due to limited disclosures.
Source: S&P Global Ratings
The downgrade underscores potential vulnerabilities in USDT’s structure, as the stablecoin’s peg stability hinges on reserve quality. S&P Global Ratings emphasized that without greater transparency, USDT faces heightened risks from asset volatility. Tether maintains that its reserves are robust, with recent attestations showing over 77% in low-risk U.S. Treasury bills and cash equivalents. However, the agency’s report highlights the remaining 23% in higher-risk categories, which grew significantly in recent quarters.
Industry experts, including analysts from financial research firms, have noted that stablecoins like USDT operate in a regulatory gray area. As the largest stablecoin by market capitalization at $184 billion—up $44 billion year-over-year—USDT’s influence on crypto markets is profound. Tether’s offshore status exempts it from strict U.S. guidelines mandating 100% backing by cash or government bonds, but this freedom comes with scrutiny. Analyst Novacula Occami pointed out that Tether’s upcoming U.S.-based product, USAT, will comply with these standards, potentially setting a new benchmark for transparency.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Are the Specific Risks Highlighted in the USDT Downgrade?
The USDT downgrade by S&P Global cites risks from reserves exposed to Bitcoin, gold, and other volatile assets, which face credit, market, and interest-rate fluctuations. Limited disclosures exacerbate these concerns, potentially straining the stablecoin’s dollar peg. Tether reports 77% of reserves in safer assets, but experts recommend fuller audits for investor confidence.
Why Did Tether’s CEO Call the Downgrade an Attack?
Paolo Ardoino described the S&P Global downgrade as an attack because Tether’s embrace of Bitcoin and gold as reserves challenges the flaws in traditional finance. He stated, “We wear your loathing with pride,” positioning Tether as proof of a broken system reliant on toxic assets. This response resonates with crypto advocates pushing for decentralized alternatives.
Key Takeaways
- USDT faces heightened scrutiny: S&P Global’s “weak” rating signals risks from high-exposure assets like BTC and gold, urging better transparency.
- Tether’s defiant stance: CEO Paolo Ardoino views the downgrade as resistance to innovation, highlighting traditional finance’s vulnerabilities.
- Reserve composition matters: With $184 billion in circulation, diversifying into safer assets could restore confidence and support USDT’s peg stability.
Conclusion
The USDT downgrade by S&P Global Ratings illuminates ongoing debates around stablecoin reserves and transparency in the crypto ecosystem. As Tether expands into gold, Bitcoin, and new ventures like AI and energy, balancing innovation with regulatory compliance will be crucial. Looking ahead, enhanced disclosures could mitigate risks, fostering greater trust among users and positioning USDT as a resilient pillar in digital finance—explore more crypto developments to stay ahead.
Tether’s CEO Pushes Back
Tether CEO Paolo Ardoino vehemently pushed back against the downgrade, framing it as an assault on the company’s role in disrupting outdated financial norms. Ardoino stated that S&P Global Ratings was upset with Tether’s strategic pivot to Bitcoin and gold, which he believes reveals the “broken system” propped up by questionable reserve practices. He remarked, “We wear your loathing with pride. Tether is living proof that the traditional financial system is so broken that it’s becoming feared by the emperors with no clothes.”
Source: X
Chris Pavlovski, CEO of Rumble, supported this view, labeling the rating as an “attack on Tether” for daring to challenge entrenched financial powers. As the issuer of the world’s premier stablecoin, Tether has seen USDT’s supply surge to $184 billion, a $44 billion increase in one year alone. Operating offshore, USDT avoids U.S. mandates for full backing by government bonds or cash, unlike Tether’s planned U.S. offering, USAT, which will prioritize transparency as noted by analyst Novacula Occami. Critics, including those from Occam’s Razor, argue the downgrade targets Tether’s broader transparency deficits rather than just USDT.
How Tether Reports Its Reserves
Tether’s latest reserve report indicates 77% of USDT is backed by short-term U.S. Treasury bills and cash equivalents, with the balance in Bitcoin, gold, and secured lending. This composition has drawn S&P Global’s ire, particularly as Tether ramped up gold purchases in Q3, becoming a top independent buyer on par with central banks.
Source: S&P Global Ratings
Tether’s strategy extends beyond stablecoins into infrastructure, data centers, AI, and energy sectors, aiming for long-term diversification. S&P Global Ratings warns that without detailed breakdowns, these allocations heighten systemic risks. Financial experts from institutions like Bloomberg and Reuters have echoed calls for independent audits, underscoring the need for stablecoins to evolve with market demands. As crypto adoption grows, Tether’s response to this downgrade could influence regulatory frameworks worldwide, ensuring USDT remains a cornerstone of digital transactions.
