AdvertiseFee Deal Desk

News

CryptoUK Urges FCA to Keep DeFi Developers Outside the Perimeter in CP26/36

CryptoUK told the FCA that DeFi development and governance alone should not trigger regulation, urging a control-based test in its CP26/36 response.

Be a creator
November 20, 2026, 11:13 AM UTC5 min read
AI SummaryAI
  • CryptoUK filed its CP26/36 response with the FCA on November 18, 2026.
  • CryptoUK represents more than 150 crypto companies in the UK.
  • The FCA plans final perimeter guidance for January 2027; the regime starts October 25, 2027.
  • Aave Labs urged the FCA to preserve self-custodial and regulated-firm access to DeFi.

A Control Test for DeFi Code

More than 150 crypto companies, represented by the UK trade association CryptoUK, have told the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) that writing or governing DeFi code should not, by default, make a person a regulated firm. The association submitted its response to CP26/36, the FCA's consultation paper on the perimeter of the new UK crypto regime, on Wednesday, November 18, the day the consultation closed, and published it a day later. The paper proposes amendments to the Perimeter Guidance Manual, the handbook that maps which activities need FCA authorization, to reflect the FSMA 2000 (Cryptoassets) (Miscellaneous Amendments) Regulations 2026 laid in September.

At the centre of the submission is a control test. CryptoUK argued that writing, maintaining or securing protocol code, and taking part in decentralized governance, are not by themselves regulated activities; the decisive question is who effectively controls a financial service, which follows the FCA's own “clear controlling person” approach to DeFi. The group said it broadly supports the draft, including new exclusions for temporary settlement and payment flows, the assets that back UK-recognized stablecoins, a firm's own-account trading and market making, and technical service providers, so desks trading their own capital rather than arranging spot trading for customers stay outside.

But the draft, in CryptoUK's words, “goes further than the legislation” in several places. The association flagged a proposed UK nexus tied to where a protocol is developed or governed, a follow-on transfer order condition on the payments exclusion, service indicators that would narrow the own-account trading carve-out, and criteria that could push technical service providers, including those whose systems set order types and routing by objective rules, out of their exclusion. A UK developer who does not actually control a protocol's financial service could still be swept in, it warned. The FCA has acknowledged that the timing of the September amendments left some firms uncertain and said it will allow extra time where questions over the technical services exclusion have stalled authorization applications.

Peers Press the Same Perimeter Point

CryptoUK's filing also asks the FCA to publish a public, machine-readable register of stablecoins that qualify under the UK regime, to spell out how such tokens differ from electronic money, and to add more worked examples of activity outside the perimeter. It wants the regulator to take adverse outcomes to the Treasury, citing UK technical providers that give access to regulated overseas venues and payments in stablecoins issued abroad, and it urges alignment with the EU's MiCA framework where appropriate. The response was prepared with law firm CMS and signed by CryptoUK policy director Nick Brooks.

Other responders pushed the same way. Aave Labs, in a joint submission on CP26/36 and the separate DeFi consultation GC26/7 also filed on November 18, argued that safeguards attached to DeFi must not become a route into the regulated perimeter, and that users should keep both direct access from their own wallet address and access through regulated firms. Requiring orders to execute only on an FCA-approved crypto exchange could, in its view, shut regulated firms out of offering DeFi altogether. Andreessen Horowitz called the draft's decentralization test vague and asked for objective measures of operational, economic and governance control. The DeFi Education Fund said a clear control test would help developers, frontend providers and authorized firms judge their UK exposure, with responsibility resting on whoever keeps control of user assets or trades.

The schedule around the paper is tight. The consultation opened on October 21. The FCA had already said, in answers published after its November 6 annual meeting, that a fully decentralized protocol with nobody performing a regulated activity sits outside the perimeter, though software used to intermediate trades can itself become one. Final guidance is planned for January 2027, and the regime takes effect on October 25, 2027. Existing UK firms can apply for authorization from September 30, 2026, with a submission deadline of February 28, 2027.

The Gap Between Code and Control

Our reading is that the dispute is not over whether DeFi touches the perimeter, but over where the draft places the trigger. The statute, as CryptoUK reads it, keys liability to control of a financial service, while the draft adds operational hooks such as a development-location nexus and conditions on exclusions that can reach actors the law does not name. Because the Perimeter Guidance Manual is guidance rather than rule text, and the FCA's own handbook states it cannot widen or narrow the regulated activities the law defines, the January 2027 final wording is where this gets settled. Firms already preparing authorization applications before the February 28, 2027 deadline must size their UK exposure against a perimeter that is still moving.

Readers tracking the market in real time can follow live spot and futures prices on Bybit.

Primary sources

COINOTAG's editorial and research desk.

AI-Assisted

AI-generated, AI-reviewed, under COINOTAG editorial oversight.

Price-Impacting News

Live
All breaking news
Breaking News