Fed Minutes Show 10-2 October Rate Hold Was a Close Call
Fed minutes show the 10-2 October rate hold was a close call, with markets pricing a December hike and officials warning of AI-related financial risks.
AI SummaryAI
- The Fed held rates at 3.75% to 4% in October on a 10-2 vote.
- Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack favored a quarter-point hike.
- Pricing puts December quarter-point hike odds near 90% and half-point odds near 10%.
- Bitcoin traded near $62,300 after the minutes, below its 200-week moving average around $68,000.
Cook and Hammack Wanted a Hike
“Close call” is how several Federal Reserve officials who backed October's decision to leave interest rates unchanged described the outcome, according to minutes released Wednesday, even as the record showed policymakers judged that further hikes would probably be needed to return inflation to 2%. The Federal Open Market Committee held its benchmark rate at 3.75% to 4% on a 10-2 vote, with Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack each favoring a quarter-point increase. A few participants who sided with the hold still viewed it as a near coin flip, a detail suggesting the committee sat closer to tightening than the tally alone implied. Lewis Huang, an analyst at Bitget, said the record points to broader support for an October hike than the vote indicated, and that the picture hardened before payrolls and CPI data both arrived hotter than expected.
Rate expectations have since consolidated around a December increase. Odds of a quarter-point move run near 90%, with roughly 10% on a half-point rise, and attention has shifted to the size of the move and the path beyond December. The repricing reached crypto quickly: bitcoin traded near $62,300 after the minutes were published, below its 200-week moving average close to $68,000, and a slide under the weekend low near $62,000 could extend the sell-off. Artificial intelligence occupied its own section of the record. Many participants noted that demand for data center equipment was straining supply and lifting consumer technology prices, with several warning the pressure was spreading beyond the industries building the infrastructure. Most also observed that AI-related debt had grown rapidly, much of it through complex and opaque financing structures, and a few remarked that exposures were concentrating among a small number of firms.
Schiff's 2008 Warning
Gold changing hands below $3,800 per troy ounce, down from a record near $5,600 in January, has pushed analysts to examine why the metal is sliding. Peter Schiff, the economist and long-standing gold advocate, places the blame with Fed Governor Christopher Waller, who has urged a half-point increase to shock the market into fighting inflation. Gold is falling, he argued in a post on X, because the Fed has committed to winning its war on inflation, and if that commitment is honored, gold will not be the only casualty. He concedes that even bullion cannot fully escape the fallout. If the Fed genuinely delivers the increases needed to curb inflation, the present market is, in his words, an outright bubble: stocks, bonds, real estate and crypto would fall far harder than gold, producing a severe recession and a financial crisis more damaging than 2008, a comparison he made in a follow-up post by likening any such outcome to a school picnic. A liquidity drain is compounding the pressure. Anthropic is set to list on Nasdaq on November 19 under the ticker ANT after the largest initial public offering on record, an $81.3 billion raise that leaves the AI company with a fully diluted market cap of $1.5 trillion. Cash flowing toward that deal, and toward AI-linked technology generally, has come at the expense of other holdings, gold and bitcoin among them. Last week, FFTT founder Luke Gromen added his own caution, saying anyone untroubled by gold's swings was not paying attention to the market. Even so, Schiff expects precious metals to fare best in a downside scenario, retaining more value than equities, property or the banking system and gaining the most from the inflationary bailout he says would follow.
@PeterSchiff · X post
A post on X.
View on X
Firm Dollar, Heavy Funding
Read together, the two threads point one way. The minutes confirm a committee sitting closer to tightening than its vote suggested, while Schiff's warning describes what a delivered hike would do to leveraged portfolios across every asset class; the mechanics of that transmission, from tech stocks to tokens, are laid out in how interest rates impact everything. For crypto specifically, the path runs through the dollar and Treasury yields: firmer long-term rates push leveraged longs to pay steeper funding rates, and the cash that cushions AMM pools thins as capital chases yield. Fabian Dori, chief investment officer at Sygnum Bank, put the balance plainly: a market pricing a series of hikes into next year keeps yields and the dollar strong, and the open question is whether debasement concerns and institutional adoption can outweigh that pressure. The policy question returns when the committee meets in December, with an increase effectively priced.
Primary sources
- a follow-up post · x.com
- x.com
AI-generated, AI-reviewed, under COINOTAG editorial oversight.

