Groundwork Says 29.1% of Amazon (AMZN) Black Friday Deals Were No Cheaper
A new report finds 29.1% of Amazon (AMZN) Black Friday deals were no cheaper than the prior 30-day low; Amazon disputes the study, citing its own 98% figure.
AI SummaryAI
- Groundwork Collaborative released Deal or Decoy? on November 16, covering 351 Amazon deal items.
- 29.1% of promotional prices matched or exceeded the lowest price of the prior 30 days.
- 9.4% of items were priced higher than the lowest price in the previous 30 days.
- Amazon says its own comparison found 98% of prices equal to or below the past 30 days.
351 Deals Across Two Holiday Seasons
Groundwork Collaborative, a United States economic policy think tank, released a study on Monday, November 16, claiming that nearly three in ten of Amazon's (AMZN) advertised Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals offered no genuine saving. Its report, “Deal or Decoy? Amazon’s Deceptive Discounts,” examined 351 products drawn from the deal pages Amazon itself curated for the two events in 2024 and 2025. In 29.1% of cases the promotional price was equal to or higher than the lowest price recorded in the 30 days before the promotion began, and in 9.4% of cases the sale price was outright higher than that prior low. About one in three promoted prices, put differently, was not a discount against the preceding month. The price history came from Keepa, a third-party tracker that records Amazon listing prices several times a day. Groundwork benchmarked each item's lowest price during the sale against its lowest price over the prior 10, 30 and 90 days, and used the 30-day window as its headline measure, citing the standard set by a European Union consumer protection directive. The deal pages listed 185 items for the 2025 Black Friday event and 152 for the 2025 Cyber Monday page, plus 53 and 26 on the two 2024 pages, with 351 included in the analysis after filtering. The examples the think tank singled out were stark. A pair of yellow Hunter women's boots listed at $126.99 during the 2025 Black Friday event had sold for $79.97 nine days earlier, a 59% premium. A pair of UGG Butte men's boots at $179.98 during Cyber Monday had cost $98.40 27 days before, an 83% premium. Among items priced above the prior low, the median gap was 19%. Over a 90-day lookback the no-saving share rose to 57.3%, with roughly 27% of deals more expensive. The think tank urged federal and state regulators to pursue misleading discounts and recommended that retailers disclose the lowest price of the prior 30 days alongside any sale tag, mirroring the EU requirement. It also noted that the Federal Trade Commission's guidance on deceptive pricing never defined what counts as a reasonably substantial reference period and has not been actively enforced since the Nixon administration. Groundwork president and co-author Lindsay Owens said shoppers waiting for the big seasonal sales may be playing “rip-off roulette,” and that lawmakers should hold the company to account if it cannot keep the basic promise.
Amazon's Same-Day Rebuttal
Amazon rejected the findings the same day in a post on its About Amazon news site, calling Groundwork a political advocacy group and the report flatly wrong and misleading, and noting it was the group's second set of claims about Amazon promotions within a week. The company said its own comparison of the items in the report found 98% of prices equal to or lower than the cheapest price over the past 30 days, rising to 99% for the 2025 events. Amazon's objections were specific. The two years of events carried more than 10 million deals, yet only 17 of its 200 bestselling promotions were included, and the sample of roughly 350 items was too small to support the conclusions. Some recorded prices, it said, were higher than what shoppers actually saw, early-access deals that ran before the events were not fully identified, and items were counted that never carried a deal badge at all, since a strikethrough reference price is a different mechanism from a badge that must meet extra quality requirements. The company said Groundwork delayed publication after Amazon flagged these errors, then dropped 2026 Prime Day data and added 2024 data. Amazon added that Groundwork declined to share its raw data, forcing the company to rebuild the item list from data partner media had been given. One methodological divergence stands out: Groundwork counts a sale price merely equal to the prior 30-day low as no saving, while Amazon's badge rule requires only that the price be equal to or below that low. Amazon said its 2025 policy already barred event prices above the prior 30-day low, that the rule was tightened again this year, and that Groundwork's removal of the 2026 data speaks for itself. It also acknowledged one error that placed a small number of unbadged items into corporate blog deal posts, saying the process has been corrected.
The exchange of accusations lands ahead of the peak shopping season. The dispute is reputational and regulatory rather than a balance-sheet event, and neither side has quantified any revenue impact. COINOTAG's glossary entries on derivatives open interest and the funding rate provide background on the positioning metrics involved.
AI-generated, AI-reviewed, under COINOTAG editorial oversight.

