AdvertiseFee Deal Desk

XRP

Ripple's David Schwartz Rejects Total XRP Scam Filtering, Citing Free Speech

Ripple CTO Emeritus David Schwartz warns total algorithmic filtering would erode free speech, as Rhode Island sues Meta over scam ads targeting XRP users.

Be a creator
October 25, 2026, 11:21 AM UTC7 min readUpdated
AI SummaryAI
  • Ripple CTO Emeritus David Schwartz rejected total algorithmic content filtering in a Saturday post on X
  • Rhode Island's attorney general sued Meta for knowingly profiting from AI-optimized scam advertising
  • Schwartz said filters removing posts on deception probability would censor millions of First Amendment-protected posts
  • Schwartz compared platform liability to holding restaurants responsible for serving food to terrorists

Update 06:53 UTC: Update, October 26: the exchange has continued to draw coverage a day after Schwartz's posts, with a crypto-focused report out of South Korea restating his position in summary form.

The Rhode Island Case Against Meta

The lawsuit Rhode Island’s attorney general filed against Meta Platforms has split Silicon Valley over who carries the cost when scammers operate on a platform, and Ripple CTO Emeritus David Schwartz has entered the dispute on the side of open feeds. Schwartz, one of the principal architects of the XRP Ledger, a settlement layer that runs a native automated market maker without any central operator, said in a post on X on Saturday that the “safe vacuum” created by total algorithmic filtering would harm free speech and paralyze the internet community’s collective defense. The argument drew wide attention among XRP holders, the community our XRP coverage follows daily, because the scam formats at issue target exactly those users. The trigger was a debate on X in which users proposed obliging platforms to run strict filters that would cut scam advertising and posts out of personal feeds, with fake “2-for-1 XRP giveaway” schemes cited as the worst abuse. Schwartz answered with a tougher but more practical cybersecurity stance: isolating experts from spam builds a dangerous information vacuum, because once fraud is pushed out of sight, opinion leaders lose the ability to identify new threats early and warn the industry in public. He framed the trade-off starkly, arguing that a feed scrubbed clean by algorithms may look safe while removing the very signals that let recognized figures flag an attack while it spreads. He also criticized regulators who load responsibility onto technology companies, saying the law should target the people who build and operate criminal schemes rather than the platforms those schemes abuse. The exchange unfolded while traders tracked the XRP price, but the substance here is legal and architectural, not market-driven.

Phishing Alerts and a Blame Shift

Schwartz does not argue from theory. He regularly identifies phishing attacks in the XRP ecosystem himself and publishes public warnings, a practice he presents as evidence that human vigilance works where automation alone does not. Phishing is the fraud method that tricks users through fake links, sites or messages into surrendering sensitive data such as passwords, private keys or wallet access, and giveaway posts are its most common crypto disguise. His alerts are frequent enough that ecosystem users treat his account as an early-warning channel before interacting with unfamiliar links. The Rhode Island complaint accuses Meta of knowingly deriving revenue from scam advertising optimized by internal AI tools, a framing Schwartz called the wrong target. He argued that automatic removal of material based solely on the “probability of deception” is a dead-end path that would produce hidden censorship of millions of legal posts protected by the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. He compared official attempts to shift blame onto IT giants to holding restaurants liable for serving food to terrorists, insisting the law should prosecute exclusively the authors of criminal schemes. Web3 developers, meanwhile, argue that the only working shield against scams is the transparency of the environment and the vigilance of the community itself, not an algorithm. In his view, the faster threats mutate across the crypto asset ecosystem, the more valuable community-based warning mechanisms become, with automation in a supporting role rather than a commanding one. The warning lands on receptive ground: giveaway fraud runs on manufactured FOMO, and XRP has traded under pressure, having tested $1.26 support after a failed rebound, which leaves holders more exposed to false recovery promises.

The market backdrop has worsened since the exchange. Analyst AliCharts warned on X on October 25 that XRP could fall to $0.98 if the channel-bottom support at $1.26 breaks, with $1.11 as the first lower level, roughly 22% below that support. The same thread points to whale distribution: wallets holding between 10 million and 100 million XRP dropped from 351 to 339 over recent weeks, while exchange holdings rose about 50 million tokens, from 11.03 billion to roughly 11.05 billion. The token traded between $1.30 and $1.31, a range that exposes holders to the false recovery promises Schwartz described.

Schwartz also addressed a separate question over the weekend: whether XRPL's success in finance would leave XRP demand and value behind. In an X post on October 23, cited via U.Today, he called a scenario in which XRPL financial applications scale widely while XRP demand and price stay low "highly unlikely." His reasoning rests on XRP's role as the ledger's base asset: fees are paid in XRP and burned, the current minimum is 10 drops per standard transaction, and the mainnet reserve is 1 XRP per account plus roughly 0.2 XRP for each held object. He noted that automated pathfinding only routes trades through XRP when the rate is more favorable, so not every tokenized transaction touches it, and Ripple's September 2025 MOU with DBS and Franklin Templeton allows clients to trade RLUSD and sgBENJI without XRP as the settlement asset.

Update, October 25: analyst Ali Martinez has expanded on the bearish setup in a follow-up thread, framing the downside case around three factors rather than one. He said on-chain and technical readings now carry growing downside risk for XRP, noting that large-holder wallets holding 10 million to 100 million XRP on the XRP Ledger fell from 351 to 339 in recent weeks, a reduction of 12 wallets that could point to position trimming and heavier selling pressure. Exchange balances stayed elevated over the past week at roughly 11.05 billion XRP, up from 11.003 billion, and Martinez argued that continued transfers to trading platforms add sellable supply. He confirmed $1.26 as the bottom of the channel XRP has traded in since August, with a break pointing first to $1.11 and then to the $0.98 level, about 22% below the support.

Update, October 26: the exchange has continued to draw coverage a day after Schwartz's posts, with a crypto-focused report out of South Korea restating his position in summary form. The recap centers on three claims: that hiding scam posts from expert view weakens the community's ability to detect and publicly warn about new threats, that Rhode Island's complaint rests on the allegation that Meta knew it was profiting from scam advertising optimized by its internal AI tools, and that automatic deletion based solely on the "probability of deception" risks suppressing millions of posts protected by the First Amendment. The report again cites the fake "send XRP, receive double" giveaway format as the abuse that started the debate, and repeats Schwartz's restaurant analogy, which places liability with the parties who design criminal schemes rather than with the platforms.

Where the Liability Line Falls

Our reading of the posture: this is a state civil complaint, not a criminal charge, and its load-bearing claim is that Meta’s internal AI optimization tools sat inside the revenue chain for scam advertising. That framing is exactly what Schwartz’s intervention contests, and it explains why the argument reaches beyond moderation policy into platform liability. For XRP holders the practical consequence is direct. No algorithm will catch every fake giveaway, so self-custody hygiene carries the defense: verify addresses at the source, never share private keys, and move long-term holdings off connected software, options that include a Ripple (XRP) paper wallet. The scam surface keeps expanding as legitimate yield products grow; Evernorth’s plan to place 473 million XRP into onchain lending gives fraudsters plausible material to imitate, which makes community-level verification the decisive control for now.

Readers tracking the market in real time can follow live spot and futures prices on Binance.

Primary sources

COINOTAG's editorial and research desk.

AI-Assisted

AI-generated, AI-reviewed, under COINOTAG editorial oversight.