SEC Nominee Johnson Backs Formal Rulemaking on Tokenized Stock Exemption
SEC nominee Kristin Johnson backs formal rulemaking on tokenized stocks after 67 issuer objections, as Steven Levine defends the exemption.
AI SummaryAI
- 67 companies objected to tokenized versions of their shares trading on the OKXICE platform.
- The SEC's September 17 exemption lets qualifying platforms trade tokenized US-listed shares for five years.
- Steven Levine compared the exemption to early ETF exemptive orders that later became rules.
- Two confirmations would expand the SEC commission to four members from two currently seated.
Kristin Johnson's Rulemaking Call
Kristin Johnson, President Trump's Democratic pick for the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), told a Senate Banking Committee confirmation hearing on Thursday that the agency's tokenization exemption should be reconsidered through a formal rule, a step she said she would welcome while market participants themselves raise objections. Johnson, a former Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) commissioner who left that agency last year and now teaches at George Washington University Law School, was nominated last week alongside Republican Steven Levine to fill two of the commission's vacancies. The session covered five nominees in total, including candidates for roles at the Treasury Department and the Department of Transportation.
Asked about dozens of companies that have objected to having their stock offered under the SEC's new tokenization approach, granted as an exemption to standing securities rules, Johnson said she would welcome moving the topic into a formal rulemaking that carries a public comment period, "especially when the stakeholders we see raising concerns are in fact market participants, registrants themselves." "Regulation is made better through the notice-and-comment period," she told the Senate Banking Committee confirmation hearing, adding that Congress requires independent federal market regulators to follow that process when they develop rules. In her prepared remarks, Johnson wrote that artificial intelligence, tokenization, stablecoins and decentralized platforms promise lower costs and wider access while raising questions about conflicts of interest, data governance and accountability. In digital asset markets, she said, her focus has been strong governance, conflicts-of-interest rules and the segregation of customer assets.
The September Exemption
The order at the center of the questioning dates from Sept. 17, when the SEC issued its innovation exemption for tokenized stock trading. Effective immediately, it lets qualifying platforms trade blockchain-based versions of U.S.-listed shares without registering as securities exchanges, provided they meet a set of conditions, and it invites public comment on possible changes to the framework.
Under the order, a qualifying venue is temporarily exempt from the exchange definition in securities law, and certain market makers that supply liquidity with their own capital are exempt from the dealer definition. The window runs five years from publication, and anti-fraud and anti-manipulation provisions continue to apply in full. Venues restrict access to permitted participants and route trading through an automated market maker and liquidity pools. Token holders must receive the same dividend and voting rights as holders of the underlying shares, issuers may object to their stock trading on such a venue, and synthetic stock-style products sit outside the exemption's scope. SEC Chairman Paul Atkins framed the measure as a first step, saying a temporary exemption should be followed by durable rulemaking. Resistance is already on the record: a public notice dated Nov. 5 lists 67 companies objecting to the tokenization of their shares on the OKXICE platform. Johnson also flagged Anti-Money Laundering and Know Your Customer compliance as concerns, noting that objections extend beyond investor protection.
Levine's Stepwise Path
Levine struck a different note. The Republican nominee, a former aide to SEC Commissioner Mark Uyeda, said he had not closely studied the innovation exemption but understood it to be time-limited and narrow, with investor protections built in. He emphasized that Congress authorized the SEC to grant exemptions from federal securities laws when doing so serves the public interest and stays consistent with investor protection requirements.
"Many innovations, such as the exchange traded fund, began as a series of exemptive orders that ultimately resulted in agency rulemaking," Levine told the panel, a framing that matches the sequencing Atkins has described: test the market with an exemption, then write the durable rule. The process now moves on a defined clock. Senators have until noon Friday to submit additional written questions to the nominees, with responses due by 5:00 p.m. ET on Nov. 24, according to the committee's closing remarks. The nominations could then advance to a committee vote before reaching the full Senate, where both would need confirmation before taking their seats. Industry voices read a bipartisan bench as a stabilizer. "Crypto isn't a partisan issue, and the rules that come out of a bipartisan commission will stand on firmer footing," said Jessica Martinez, U.S. policy director at digital asset infrastructure firm Fireblocks. Even a minority commissioner, she added, can shape policy by challenging proposals and pushing unresolved issues to be addressed before rules are finalized.
Prediction Market Jurisdiction
The nominees also fielded questions on prediction markets. Senator Catherine Cortez Masto, a Nevada Democrat, accused firms of illegally trading security-based swaps packaged as equity-based perpetuals, a reference to the CFTC's recent allowance for single-stock perpetual futures, a form of contract trading that carries no expiry date. Levine declined to commit to a position. Johnson said there are "very critical and important questions" regarding the commission's jurisdiction and authority.
The politics around the panel itself may weigh as much as any single answer. The banking committee was central to this year's failed negotiations over the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act, a process Democratic Senator Mark Warner called "a year in crypto hell." Senator Elizabeth Warren, the ranking Democrat expected to take the chairmanship when her party takes the majority in January, has been among the Senate's loudest crypto skeptics, and she greeted Levine with a pointed question about whether he would be "just another pawn" putting Wall Street profits over American investors. Even so, the session produced few fireworks. If both nominees are confirmed, the commission would move from two seated members to four, three Republicans and one Democrat, with a Democratic seat still vacant. Earlier this week, the Senate Agriculture Committee held a parallel hearing for the CFTC nominees, Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick, where senators pressed the jurisdiction dispute between the regulator and state authorities, a fight that has produced dozens of lawsuits and appeals and may reach the U.S. Supreme Court.
Exemption First, Rule Later
The two nominees disagree on process, not on destination. Johnson wants the tokenization framework tested through notice-and-comment; Levine, and Atkins before him, are content to let the five-year exemption run first and gather evidence. The 67 issuer objections now give that formal record its weight, and whichever path the commission takes, tokenized stocks are the test case for how U.S. regulators treat blockchain-based representations of assets more broadly, a market where Bitcoin (BTC) remains the benchmark instrument. Written answers are due Nov. 24, and a committee vote followed by a full Senate confirmation is expected soon after.
Primary sources
- Senate Banking Committee confirmation hearing · banking.senate.gov
- innovation exemption · sec.gov
AI-generated, AI-reviewed, under COINOTAG editorial oversight.

