AdvertiseFee Deal Desk

Price Moves

S&P 500's 7.1% Drop Is the 34th Correction Above 5% Since 2009, Bilello Says

The S&P 500 has dropped as much as 7.1% from its high of October 6, the benchmark's third pullback of 2026 and, by one long-run measure, a…

Be a creator
November 18, 2026, 11:15 AM UTC4 min read
AI SummaryAI
  • The S&P 500 fell as much as 7.1% from its October 6 high, the third pullback of 2026.
  • Charlie Bilello counts the drop as the 34th correction above 5% since the March 2009 low.
  • The index closed Tuesday at 7,340.53, its lowest level since July 29.
  • Citi strategists say 95% of S&P 500 futures longs, worth about $45.9 billion, are underwater.

A 7.1% Slide From the October 6 High

The S&P 500 has dropped as much as 7.1% from its high of October 6, the benchmark's third pullback of 2026 and, by one long-run measure, a shallower-than-typical one. Creative Planning chief market strategist Charlie Bilello counts the move as the 34th correction above 5% since the March 2009 low. In a chart published on his X account, Bilello noted that the median correction in that span ran 7.6% deep over 26 days; the current episode is smaller in magnitude but older, stretching across 42 days. “They all seemed like the end of the world at the time,” he wrote of the series. Two earlier pullbacks bookend the year: the first, from January 28 to March 30, reached 9.8%, and a seven-day dip in early June stopped at 5.0%. None of the three has crossed 10%, despite Fundstrat Global Advisors head of research Tom Lee calling for a 10% correction back in August. Bilello's table lists the Iran war, inflation and Federal Reserve (Fed) hike fears, and AI spending and debt worries as the drivers behind the drawdowns. St. Louis Fed President Alberto Musalem signaled on Tuesday that several further rate increases may still be needed, and the index closed that session at its lowest level since July 29 after a fourth straight daily loss. The close printed 7,340.53, or 6.4% below the high; the 7.1% figure measures the 7,288 intraday low instead. Futures rose that night after Nvidia (NVDA) posted better-than-expected earnings. For holders of an S&P 500 ETF, the historical table is steadying: only 10 of the 34 corrections since 2009 ran past 10%, the deepest being a 35.4% drop in 2020 over 33 days, while the longest, a 282-day slide in 2022, fell 27.5% and listed the same inflation and Fed tightening causes.

Citi Puts 95% of Futures Longs Underwater

Positioning data tells a more brittle story. A Citi positioning analysis from strategists led by David Chew puts S&P 500 futures long exposure at roughly $45.9 billion, with an average entry near 7,768 against a market level around 7,573, leaving 95% of long positions in loss. The index has rallied about 2.5% from the lows, but the team says the improvement in US positioning has come mainly from short covering rather than new long capital: investors are cutting bearish bets, not turning more constructive. Citi warns that if the bounce fails to hold, losing longs could unwind together and amplify the downside. The breakdown differs sharply by market. Nasdaq positioning has returned to neutral, while the Russell 2000 remains among the most concentrated short markets globally, with most of those shorts in profit; the team flags a dovish shift in Fed expectations or softer-than-expected inflation data as catalysts that could force covering there. Europe is the only major region showing broad new longs: the Euro Stoxx 50 has drawn about $4.9 billion of fresh risk capital with little covering involved, and German DAX and UK FTSE positioning has improved alongside it. Yet every major European index short sits underwater, with the largest book on the Euro Stoxx 50 at $7.3 billion and an average entry of 6,155 against a current level near 6,397. European bank stock shorts rank at the 94th percentile historically, with an average loss of 3.4%. In Asia, the Nikkei 225 and China A50 carry large profitable short books that could accelerate any rally if closed for gains. Citi adds that inflation data published last week still showed sticky price pressure, tilting expectations for the Fed further toward hawkish.

Fragile Books on Both Sides of the Trade

Read together, the two datasets frame the same market from opposite ends. Bilello's 34-correction record says a shallow 7% drawdown is normal and has historically resolved without becoming a bear market. Citi's book, though, shows the recent 2.5% rebound rests on covering rather than conviction, with no new long capital behind it. The line that matters is whether the index keeps its footing near 7,573, below the futures cohort's 7,768 average entry, or whether underwater longs start cutting into the bounce. A moving average alone will not settle that question; the positioning data, the next inflation readings and the Fed's rate path will decide whether this 34th correction follows the shallow median or breaks the pattern.

Primary sources

COINOTAG's editorial and research desk.

AI-Assisted

AI-generated, AI-reviewed, under COINOTAG editorial oversight.

Price-Impacting News

Live
All breaking news
Breaking News