S&P Holds Tether's USDT at Weakest Stability Score as Riskier Assets Reach 28%
S&P Global Ratings held Tether's USDT at its weakest stability score of 5 as higher-risk assets rose to 28% of supply; Tether rejects the framework.
AI SummaryAI
- S&P Global Ratings held USDT at stability score 5, its scale's weakest grade, on Nov. 18.
- Higher-risk assets rose to 28% of circulating USDT as of Sept. 30, from 24% a year earlier.
- Tether's gold holdings grew from $12.9 billion to about $19 billion over the year.
- Tether reported $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in liabilities, a 104.3% ratio.
Higher-Risk Assets Reach 28% of Supply
Higher-risk assets now equal 28% of the supply behind Tether (USDT), the share that kept the world's largest stablecoin at the weakest grade on S&P Global Ratings' five-point stability scale. In an assessment dated Nov. 18, the agency's review assigned the token a score of 5, its lowest label, unchanged from November 2025, when the grade was cut from 4 on concern that Bitcoin holdings had reached roughly 5.6% of tokens in circulation. The assessment measures an issuer's ability to hold its dollar peg; it is not a formal credit rating, and 5 is the floor of a scale that runs down from 1. S&P found that assets it classes as higher risk, from corporate bonds to secured loans, stood at 28% of circulating supply as of Sept. 30, up from 24% a year earlier, and warned that a significant drop in their value could leave USDT undercollateralized. The agency did concede one point in the issuer's favor: the USDT price has tracked its dollar target closely over the past 12 months. Tether rejected the outcome outright, arguing that defects in S&P's methodology produced it. “The problem is S&P's framework, not our reserves,” the company said, invoking the 2008 financial crisis and its portrayal in The Big Short.
Gold at $19B While Bitcoin Holdings Shrink
Reserve composition carried the year's change. Gold holdings climbed from $12.9 billion in September 2025 to roughly $19 billion a year later, moving from 7% to about 10% of tokens outstanding, and $4.2 billion of publicly traded equities entered the book for the first time. The Bitcoin position moved the other way, from $9.9 billion, about 6%, to $8.4 billion, about 5%. S&P's higher-risk category also spans corporate bonds, secured loans and other instruments exposed to market prices, interest rates and borrower creditworthiness. The core of the stack remains short-dated U.S. debt, the plainest TradFi asset in the mix: Treasury bills with average residual maturity under 90 days equal 67% of outstanding USDT, overnight reverse repurchase agreements backed by Treasuries 5%, other repo and non-Treasury bonds 4%, and cash and bank deposits under 0.5%. Direct and indirect T-bill exposure totals $132.4 billion, with bills and reverse repos generating most of the issuer's operating income. Tether's own figures, attested by BDO Italia, show $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in total liabilities at the end of September, a collateralization ratio of 104.3%. The company's own release puts the excess reserve buffer at $7.95 billion, nearly double the $4.11 billion recorded at the end of June, on quarterly net operating profit of $1.5 billion. S&P's objection is arithmetical: the higher-risk book substantially exceeds that surplus.
KPMG Audit Leaves the Disclosure Question Open
Transparency divides the two sides as sharply as asset risk does. In August Tether announced the completion of its first full independent audit, with KPMG U.S. issuing an unqualified opinion on financial statements for the year ended Dec. 31, 2025; the issuer says every gold bar was physically inspected and counted. S&P counters that the statements, accompanying notes and auditor's report remain unavailable to the public, that quarterly reserve reports name no custodians, banking partners or counterparties, and that disclosures on the makeup and credit quality of secured loans and corporate bonds fall short. Jurisdiction is part of the dispute. Tether relocated from the British Virgin Islands to El Salvador in 2025 and answers to the National Commission of Digital Assets, which requires one dollar of reserve assets for every dollar issued and 70% of reserves in assets liquidatable within 30 days. S&P considers that definition too broad, since it admits Bitcoin, gold and loans without reserve segregation, and says public information is insufficient to judge how USDT reserves would be protected if the issuer's other ventures, which include artificial intelligence and Bitcoin mining, ran into difficulty; Tether maintains those operations are managed separately from the reserves. Redemption stays gated: only verified customers holding at least $100,000 in tokens qualify, paying a $150 verification charge and a redemption fee of $1,000 or 0.1%, whichever is higher. Secondary spot trading liquidity partially offsets those limits, though direct redemption payments follow banking hours. Distribution concentrates on three chains: as of Oct. 25, Tron carried 50.7% of outstanding USDT, Ethereum 46.8% and Solana 1.6%, together hosting 99.1%. Circle's USDC, by contrast, drew a 2 (Strong) grade from S&P in December 2025.
Buffer Trails the Risk Book
Our reading of the Nov. 18 assessment: the peg is not in question today; the question is what a downturn would do to the backing. The $7.95 billion surplus is real and growing, but the higher-risk book behind the 28% reading is several times that size, so a sharp drawdown in gold, equities or loans could outrun the buffer in a redemption wave. That risk is contingent rather than current: S&P itself credits the token's 12-month peg record, and depth across secondary venues keeps USDT convertible even where direct redemption is gated, a point our report on Binance's USDT wallets holding $1.06 billion more tokens than customer balances illustrates from the demand side. The disclosure gap is the harder constraint: without named custodians or public statements, counterparties cannot price the credit risk S&P flags, and the contrast with USDC's 2 (Strong) grade shows the market's two largest dollar tokens are now judged on different information sets. After stablecoin supply shed $14.2 billion in 30 days earlier this quarter, the cost of any confidence shock to the largest dollar token is higher than it was a year ago.
AI-generated, AI-reviewed, under COINOTAG editorial oversight.

