Blockstream Researchers Publish 131-Page Security Analysis for Bitcoin (BTC)
Researchers at Blockstream published a 131-page security analysis of SHRINCS, a proposed post-quantum signature scheme for Bitcoin (BTC), releasing the…
AI SummaryAI
- Blockstream researchers published a 131-page SHRINCS security analysis on November 18.
- The report estimates 121.4 to 122.7 bits of security against classical attackers.
- SHRINCS stateful signatures run 548 to 4,619 bytes; the stateless fallback spans 5,777 bytes.
- Authors state SHRINCS has not passed an independent audit and is not deployment-ready.
Blockstream Researchers Publish 131-Page Security Analysis
Researchers at Blockstream published a 131-page security analysis of SHRINCS, a proposed post-quantum signature scheme for
Bitcoin (BTC), releasing the document on November 18. It supplies the design's first formal security arguments while warning that the scheme has not passed an independent audit and is not ready for deployment. The 131-page analysis is credited to Blockstream researcher Mikhail Kudinov, with research director Jonas Nick and other collaborators listed alongside him. The paper evaluates SHRINCS against both classical and quantum adversaries. Under the authors' framework, the scheme delivers roughly 121.4 to 122.7 bits of security against classical attackers. The report also derives quantum security bounds, though some of those results rest on conjectures that remain unproven. The document covers the BIP draft the team first made public in August. Its authors are direct about status: the paper states SHRINCS has not undergone independent security auditing and is not fit for deployment yet. "We need as much feedback as possible, from engineers, cryptographers and protocol developers," Kudinov wrote in a post pointing to the August draft. "There is a lot to check, to test, to criticize or to praise." The work lands amid rising scrutiny of quantum computing's long-term threat to Bitcoin's elliptic curve cryptography. Google researchers demonstrated in October a technique called magic state cultivation that cut certain error rates 40-fold, a step toward more reliable machines, and researchers warn capable quantum computers could exist within years. The report itself is protocol-layer work and makes no claim on the Bitcoin (BTC) price.
Smaller Signatures, Harder Wallets
SHRINCS, short for Shrunken SPHINCS, builds on SHA-256, the same hash function that secures the network's proof of work, rather than importing the fresh mathematical assumptions behind rival post-quantum candidates. The design packs two signing methods under a single public key. Its primary stateful mode produces signatures of 548 to 4,619 bytes; the stateless fallback produces 5,777-byte signatures. Both dwarf the 64-byte Schnorr signature
Bitcoin (BTC) uses today, a compactness the Segregated Witness upgrade helped preserve, but the stateful option exists to limit the block-space pressure and fee inflation a post-quantum migration would otherwise impose. The tradeoff is operational risk. If wallet software reuses a one-time signing key across two transactions, an attacker can forge signatures and drain funds. SHRINCS counters by requiring wallets to permanently record every signing event before a signature is produced. When that record becomes unreliable, for example during recovery from a mnemonic, the software must switch to the larger stateless signatures, a fallback that raises costs for users restoring wallets or running several devices. Nick spelled out the wider cost in a video interview published Thursday: "We don't know what the fee market looks like once these huge signatures are adopted," he said. "Fewer transactions per block also means fewer people able to use
Bitcoin (BTC). I think that changes Bitcoin's value proposition." Critics moved early. Project Eleven researchers argued in an August review that prioritizing chain efficiency shifts unacceptable security risk onto wallet users, and proposed a purely stateless alternative paired with a block-capacity adjustment. Ledger CTO Charles Guillemet has raised separate concerns about wallet compatibility, hardware performance and the difficulty of reproducing existing Bitcoin features, including certain multisignature schemes and public key derivation methods.
Block Space Sets the Stakes
The publication marks a milestone in a migration question that has no clean answer yet. No quantum computer has broken Bitcoin's cryptography, but Google's earlier estimate put roughly 6.9 million BTC in outputs whose public keys are exposed, a cohort that includes long-dormant whale holdings. A parallel proposal, BIP-361, would eventually block spending from legacy addresses that miss a multi-year migration window, a step critics warn could strand inactive coins permanently. SHRINCS answers only part of the problem: how to authorize transactions once quantum-resistant signatures exist. Its authors concede unsettled mathematical assumptions remain, and adoption would still require protocol changes, implementation testing and developer consensus. The argument also brushes Bitcoin Maximalism, which treats the asset's supply scarcity as its core value case; Nick's warning is that usable block space is scarce too, and oversized signatures shrink it. For now, the team has staked its next step on open scrutiny, asking engineers and cryptographers to check, test, criticize or praise the draft in its own stated terms.
AI-generated, AI-reviewed, under COINOTAG editorial oversight.

